| |
|
|
Canadian Court or Tribunal
Canadian Court says criminalisation of polygamy is a valid limitation on the right to freedom and liberty Reference re: Section 293 of the Criminal Code of Canada 2011 BCSC 1588 (23 November 2011) Summary This case was referred to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of British Columbia, Canada to determine the constitutionality of [...]
Occupy Toronto and limitations on the right to protest Batty v City of Toronto [2011] ONSC 6862 (21 November 2011) Summary In Batty v City of Toronto, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice considered an application challenging the constitutional validity of a Trespass Notice issued to a group of protestors on the basis it violated [...]
Warrantless search of home by police justified exclusion of evidence from criminal proceedings R v Larson, 2011 BCCA 454 (10 November 2011) Summary In this case, the Court of Appeal for British Columbia overturned Mr Larson’s conviction for unlawful production of cannabis under s 7(1) of the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, SC 1996, c [...]
Supreme Court of British Columbia refuses to admit evidence obtained in breach of Charter rights R v Nakamura, 2011 BCSC 1443 (26 October 2011) Summary This case concerns a voir dire ruling made by the Supreme Court of British Columbia to exclude from the proceedings an incriminating statement made by one of the two accused [...]
Combating drug use while respecting Charter rights Canada (Attorney-General) v PHS Community Services Society, 2011 SCC 44 (30 September 2011) Summary The Supreme Court of Canada has held that the failure of the Minister of Health to grant an exemption to allow a safe injecting facility to operate notwithstanding federal anti-drug laws violated the right [...]
Solicitor-client privilege: sacred principle or conduit for crime? Federation of Law Societies of Canada v Canada (Attorney General), 2011 BCSC 1270 (27 September 2011) Summary In the context of international pressure on states to combat anti-money laundering and terrorism financing, the Supreme Court of British Columbia has held that limitations on solicitor-client privilege imposed by [...]
Canadian Appeal Court considers scope of the right to legal counsel R v JWC, 2011 ONCA 550 (10 August 2011) Summary This is an unusual criminal law case in which the only evidence against the defendant, JWC, was a statement he made to police in which he confessed to numerous sexual assaults of a number [...]
Age Discrimination Permissible for Widows’ Death Benefits Withler v Canada (Attorney General) [2011] SCC 12 (4 March 2011) Summary In response to a class action brought on behalf of widows receiving spousal death benefits, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) has reviewed Canadian jurisprudence regarding the violation of the right to substantive equality under s [...]
Sufficient Flexibility to Preserve Right to Fair Trail R v Ahmad, 2011 SCC 6 (10 February 2011) Summary The Supreme Court of Canada has held that a two court scheme regulating the disclosure of information relating to international relations, national defence or national security in criminal proceedings does not violate the right to a fair trial. Properly [...]
Right to Free Expression and Open Justice may Permit Broadcasting of Evidence Canadian Broadcasting Corp v Canada, 2011 SCC 3 (28 January 2011) Summary The Supreme Court of Canada (the Court) held that the broadcasting of a video recording of a pre-trial statement tendered in evidence at trial may be protected by the right to [...]
‘Freedom of Religion is Not Absolute’: Same-Sex Marriage and Religious Beliefs and Convictions In the Matter of Marriage Commissioners Appointed Under The Marriage Act, 1995, 2011 SKCA 3 (10 January 2011) In a landmark ruling, the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan, In the Matter of Marriage Commissioners Appointed Under The Marriage Act, 1995 (Marriage Commissioner [...]
Disability Discrimination in Access to Education British Columbia (Ministry of Education) v Moore, 2010 BCCA 478 (29 October 2010) Frederick Moore filed a human rights complaint against the Board of Trustees School Division and the Ministry of Education. He alleged the Board and the Ministry had discriminated against his dyslexic son Jeffrey and other severely [...]
Balancing the Right to a Fair Hearing and the Right to Religion: Canadian Court Considers Wearing of Veil in Criminal Proceeding R v NS, 2010 ONCA 670 (13 October 2010) The Ontario Court of Appeal recently handed down a significant decision regarding the conflict between the constitutional rights of a witness in a criminal proceeding [...]
Sex Workers Must not be Forced to Choose between their Right to Liberty and Right to Security of Person Bedford v Canada, 2010 ONSC 4264 (28 September 2010) In September 2010, the Superior Court of Justice of Ontario (Canada) struck down ss 210, 212(1)(j) and 213(1)(c) of the Criminal Code, which criminalised certain aspects of [...]
Canadian Court Considers Content of Right to Equality and Role of Appellate Courts in Discrimination Matters Ayangma v French School Board, 2010 PECA 16 (9 September 2010) The decision reviews the Supreme Court of Canada’s jurisprudence in regards to the violation of the human right to equality under s 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of [...]
What Level of Inquiry and Analysis is Required to Determine the Reasonableness of a Police Search? R v Cornell, 2010 SCC 31 (30 July 2010) The Supreme Court of Canada has considered the level of inquiry and analysis required to be conducted by police when determining whether a forced entry into a premise is reasonable, [...]
When Will Damages be a Just and Appropriate Remedy for Breach of Human Rights? City of Vancouver v Ward 2010 SCC 27 (23 July 2010) The Supreme Court of Canada has handed down a significant judgment on the availability of damages for a breach of human rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom. [...]
Access to Information and Freedom of Expression Ontario (Public Safety and Security) v Criminal Lawyers’ Association, 2010 SCC 23 (17 June 2010) The Supreme Court of Canada held that the right to freedom of expression in s 2(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms does not guarantee access to all documents held in [...]
Administrative Tribunals have Jurisdiction and Duty to Consider Human Rights Issues R v Conway, 2010 SCC 22 (11 June 2010) The Supreme Court of Canada has held that administrative tribunals with the authority to apply the law, have the jurisdiction to apply the Charter to the issues that arise in the proper exercise of their [...]
Balancing the Right to Freedom of Expression and the Right to a Fair Trial Toronto Star Newspapers Ltd v Canada, 2010 SCC 21 (10 June 2010) Legislation providing for mandatory publication bans on bail application hearings was upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada as a reasonable compromise between protecting the accused person’s right to [...]
Freedom of Expression and the Protection of Journalistic Sources: When Can a Journalist be Compelled to Reveal their Source? R v National Post, 2010 SCC 16 (7 May 2010) In this case, the Canadian Supreme Court found that the guarantee of freedom of expression in s 2(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms [...]
Proof of Identity Requirements and Limitations on the Right to Vote Henry v Canada (Attorney General), 2010 BCSC 610 (4 May 2010) This case concerned the constitutional validity of voter identification rules, which require electors to provide proof of their identity and residence in order to vote in Canadian federal elections. The Supreme Court of [...]
Hate Speech and the Limits of Freedom of Expression and Religious Belief Whatcott v Saskatchewan (Human Rights Tribunal), 2010 SKCA 26 (25 February 2010) The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan has unanimously held that four flyers, which contained anti-gay sentiments, were not so extreme as to violate that prohibition on hate speech under The Saskatchewan [...]
Right to Liberty and Security and the Police Use of Force: Excessive Use of Force Results in Reduction of Sentence R v Nasogaluak, 2010 SCC 6 (19 February 2010) The Canadian Supreme Court has held that the excessive use of force by police officers in conducting an arrest was a breach of the accused’s right [...]
Human Rights and Foreign Policy: Supreme Court Considers Canada’s Obligation to Protect the Human Rights of Citizens Abroad Canada (Prime Minister) v Khadr, 2010 SCC 3 (29 January 2010) The Canadian Supreme Court has confirmed that Canadian officials breached Omar Khadr’s right to liberty and security of the person under s 7 of the Charter [...]
Safe-Injecting Rooms, Public Health and the Right to Life and Security of Person PHS Community Services Society v Canada (Attorney General), 2010 BCCA 15 (15 January 2010) The British Columbia Court of Appeal has held that the denial of access to health care services, including safe injecting facilities, for people with severe drug dependency may [...]
Canadian Court Declares that Prison Conditions Violate Fundamental Human Rights Trang v Alberta (Edmonton Remand Centre), 2010 ABQB 6 (11 January 2010) The Court of Queen’s Bench of Alberta has declared that conditions under which untried prisoners were held in Edmonton Remand Centre (‘ERC’) pending trial for conspiracy to traffic illicit drugs resulted in a [...]
Freedom of Expression and Protection from Defamation: Striking the Right Balance Grant v Torstar Corp, 2009 SCC 61 (22 December 2009) This Canadian Supreme Court decision draws on the freedom of expression guarantee in the Canadian Charter to establish a new common law defence of ‘responsible public interest journalism’ to an action for defamation. The [...]
Homelessness and the Right to Life, Liberty and Security Victoria (City) v Adams, 2009 BCCA 563 (9 December 2009) The British Columbia Court of Appeal has held that a city bylaw which prohibited homeless people from erecting any form of temporary shelter at night in a public park, in circumstances where the number of homeless [...]
Equality and Public Authorities: Court Considers Exclusion of Female Ski Jumpers from Winter Olympics and Paralympics Sagen v Vancouver Organizing Committee for the 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games, 2009 BCCA 522 (20 November 2009) The British Columbian Court of Appeal has confirmed that the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms does not apply [...]
Governmental Obligations in Foreign Affairs and to Citizens Abroad Canada (Prime Minister) v Khadr, 2009 FCA 246 (14 August 2009) A majority of the Canadian Federal Court of Appeal recently held that Canada’s discretion to decide whether and when to request the return of a Canadian citizen detained in a foreign country, a matter within [...]
Freedom of Religion May be Limited where Effects of Limitation are Proportionate and Justifiable Alberta v Hutterian Brethren of Wilson Colony, 2009 SCC 37 (24 July 2009) In a 4:3 decision handed down on 24 July 2009, the Supreme Court of Canada allowed an appeal regarding the constitutionality of a regulation requiring photographs be taken [...]
Freedom of Expression and Restrictions on Political Advertising Greater Vancouver Transportation Authority v Canadian Federation of Students – British Columbia Component, 2009 SCC 31 (10 July 2009) The Canadian Supreme considered advertisements on public buses and held that a policy prohibiting political advertisements amounted to a breach of the right to freedom of expression under [...]
Supreme Court of Canada Balances the Right to Freedom of Religion and the Best Interests of Children AC v Manitoba (Director of Child and Family Services), 2009 SCC 30 (26 June 2009) On 26 June 2009, the Canadian Supreme Court handed down a decision which discussed in detail the right of adolescents to make their [...]
Unreasonable Delay in Criminal Proceedings: Supreme Court of Canada Holds 30 Month Delay Unconstitutional R v Godin, 2009 SCC 26 (CanLII) (4 June 2009) The Supreme Court of Canada upheld an appeal for a stay of proceedings where there was a delay of 30 months between the accused being charged and brought to trial. The [...]
Obligations of States to Citizens Detained Abroad Khadr v Canada (Minister for Justice) [2009] FC 405 On 23 April 2009, the Federal Court of Canada handed down a decision which discussed in detail the right of citizens to request their government to provide protection against acts which violate accepted norms of international law during a [...]
Canadian Supreme Court Considers Right to Privacy R v Patrick, 2009 SCC 17 (CanLII) (9 April 2009) The Supreme Court of Canada has held that no privacy interest exists in the contents of garbage bags placed out for collection. Police had seized garbage bags from an individual’s property, and used their contents to justify obtaining [...]
Freedom of Expression and Public Participation in Decision-Making Dixon v Powell River (City), 2009 BCSC 406 (CanLII) (26 March 2009) This case held that the Canadian common law should, wherever possible, be interpreted and developed to accord with the rights in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Garson J declined to follow earlier defamation [...]
Indefinite Detention Violates the Right to Liberty and Security of Person Canada (Citizenship and Immigration) v Li, 2009 FCA 85 (CanLII) (17 March 2009) The Federal Court of Appeal of Canada (‘FCA’) has held that indefinite detention is a violation of the right to liberty and security of person. Facts The Respondents are brothers Dong [...]
Discrimination on the Ground of Poverty Boulter v Nova Scotia Power Incorporation, 2009 NSCA 17 (CanLII) (13 February 2009) This decision of the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal considered whether discrimination on the grounds of poverty is contrary to the right to equality under the Canadian Charter of Rights. The Court held that poverty is [...]
The Supreme Court of British Colombia in Canada has made declarations that certain by-laws, enacted by the City of Victoria, violated s 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms as they deprived homeless people of their right to life, liberty and security. The effect of this declaration was that those by-laws are of [...]
This case concerned an application for special costs. The Supreme Court of British Columbia held that the proceeding was public interest litigation, and that special costs could therefore be awarded to the plaintiffs. Detailed case note.
The Supreme Court of Canada has again emphasised the importance of the common law evolving in a manner that is consistent with Charter values. This was a private law defamation case involving a controversial radio talk show host, ‘M’, and a social activist opposed to any positive portrayal of a gay lifestyle, ‘S’. M publicly [...]
The Supreme Court of British Columbia has held that the decisions of a Provincial Court and a public official to authorise medically-necessary blood transfusions for four infants against the express wishes of their parents did not breach the parents’ rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Detailed case note.
In a significant recent decision, the Supreme Court of Canada held that proactive schemes which seek to ameliorate the conditions of disadvantaged groups do not contravene the guarantee of equality in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In doing so, the Court re-emphasised the Canadian Charter’s concern with substantive equality. Detailed case note.
The Supreme Court of Canada recently considered the validity of a rebuttable presumption that minors committing serious offences should be sentenced as adults. A majority of the Court concluded that the presumption offended against the right not to be deprived of liberty otherwise than in accordance with principles of fundamental justice under s 7 of [...]
The Supreme Court of British Columbia recently declared that laws which made safe self-injecting rooms illegal were unconstitutional and incompatible with the rights to life, liberty and security of the person in the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms. Detailed case note.
The scope and application of the right to freedom of expression in a commercial context has recently been considered by the UK Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada. While neither court recognised a ‘corporate right’ to freedom of expression, both cases held that the right may be engaged by expression about commercial [...]
On 23 February 2007, the Supreme Court of Canada overturned provisions of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act 2001 (Can) relating to the detention of permanent residents and foreign nationals on the basis that the provisions contravened the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Canadian Parliament was given one year to rewrite the IRPA [...]
|
|
|
|
